The U.S. housing market is becoming more favorable to buyers as a growing number of homeowners put their properties up for sale. New Redfin data shows the total number of homes for sale reached its highest level since 2020 in August, while new listings climbed to their highest level in more than four years.
New listings increased 2.6% from July and 4.3% from a year earlier, giving buyers a larger selection heading into the fall. The increase was particularly strong in San Jose, Nashville and Seattle, where new listings rose 25.5%, 15.8% and 13.7%, respectively, from a year earlier.
The increase in supply is happening as demand remains relatively subdued. That imbalance is giving buyers something they have lacked for much of the past several years: negotiating power.
Redfin found that three in five homes sold below their original asking price in August, a sign that sellers are increasingly having to adjust their expectations to get deals completed. More inventory means buyers can compare multiple properties, take more time before making an offer and negotiate more aggressively when a home has been sitting on the market.
More Homes, More Choices
The growth in inventory represents a meaningful change from the severe supply shortages that characterized the pandemic housing boom.
For years, homeowners with low mortgage rates were reluctant to sell because replacing a 3% mortgage with a loan near 7% could dramatically increase their monthly payment. That "mortgage-rate lock-in" effect restricted the number of homes coming onto the market.
That pressure is beginning to ease. Some homeowners are now listing because they need to move, while others appear to have accepted that mortgage rates may remain elevated for longer than expected. Redfin economists also point to sellers adjusting to a slower housing market as another reason for the increase in listings.
The result is a market with considerably more options for buyers.
Still, rising inventory does not mean home prices are falling nationwide. The median U.S. sale price increased 2.2% from a year earlier, showing that the additional supply has not yet translated into a broad price decline.
That distinction is important. The current housing market is becoming more balanced, but it is not experiencing a nationwide collapse in values.
The Market Is Splitting by Region
The national numbers also mask major differences between individual markets.
Seattle has seen one of the largest increases in available homes, with active listings up 24.2% year over year in August. Boston followed with an 18.7% increase, while San Jose posted a 17.7% gain.
Meanwhile, San Francisco remains considerably tighter. Its median sale price increased 7.5% year over year in August to about $1.6 million, while San Jose's median price fell 2% to approximately $1.5 million.
Other markets are experiencing an even clearer shift toward buyers. Years of construction have left places such as Nashville with abundant choices, allowing buyers to take their time and forcing sellers to compete more aggressively.
That regional divide is likely to become increasingly important as buyers and sellers adjust to a housing market that no longer behaves the same way across the country.
What It Means for Buyers and Sellers
For buyers, the increase in inventory creates opportunities that were difficult to find during the housing shortage. A larger selection can make it easier to find a home that fits a particular budget, while the growing number of properties selling below their original asking price suggests that the first offer does not necessarily have to be the final offer.
For sellers, however, the environment is becoming more demanding. Simply putting a home on the market is no longer enough to guarantee strong interest. Overpricing a property can lead to longer marketing times, price reductions and eventually concessions.
Mortgage rates remain another major obstacle. Even with more homes available, borrowing costs continue to limit how much many households can afford. That helps explain why supply can rise without triggering a corresponding surge in sales.
The latest numbers therefore point to a housing market undergoing a gradual shift rather than a dramatic correction.
More homeowners are selling, buyers have more choices, and negotiations are becoming more common—yet home prices are still holding up nationally.
For the first time in years, the biggest change may not be the direction of home prices but who has the leverage at the negotiating table. As inventory continues to build, buyers are gaining room to negotiate, while sellers are increasingly being forced to compete for the households still willing and able to buy.
Discussion
Thoughts from readers and local market watchers.